Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Saltwater Fish & Invertebrates Discussion
Post Reply
User avatar
Gerwin
Discus Member
Posts: 1498
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 3:41 pm
My SetUp: Custom profile field not completed.

Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by Gerwin » Tue Nov 17, 2009 10:13 pm

Words,

but first let me say I have been selling a salt for more than 25 years called Instant Ocean, it has never let me down, I also carry Oceanic Sea Salt which has served us well.
But when I was in Atlanta getting the behind the scene tour of the largest aquarium in the world, I saw this and it all became clear
Image

jenningsxxx
Guppy Member
Posts: 13
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2009 10:42 pm
My SetUp: Custom profile field not completed.

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by jenningsxxx » Wed Nov 18, 2009 1:36 pm

I tested the Oceanic Sea Salt for Iodide, it was almost undetectable. I did the same test with Instant Ocean and it tested at .03 (Sea water is .03) It seems the cheeper salt is the better salt.

User avatar
Doug
Site Admin
Posts: 229
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 11:26 am
My SetUp: 1984: 90 gal. saltwater, O'Dell tank, Oceanic Systems cabinet stand, (2) Perfecto 48" strip lights with Vita-Lite Power Twists, Aqualogy Bio-Grade Plus Undergravel filter, (2) Hagen Aquaclear 800 power heads, Eheim 2217 canister filter with Chemi-Pure, Hawaiian Marine Angstrom 2537 UV sterilizer

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by Doug » Wed Nov 18, 2009 3:26 pm

We used to push hw MarineMix (aka Hawaiian Marine) back in the day, and briefly tried Marine Environment salt, but they had no distribution down here. It didn't prove any more popular than the hw, though.

User avatar
Sandy
Discus Member
Posts: 772
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:25 am
My SetUp: 180gal saltwater reef, 6-80watt T5 lights, 2 powerheads in tank, 2 return pumps in a 40gal sump, uv sterilizer, gfo and carbon reactor.

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by Sandy » Wed Nov 18, 2009 8:09 pm

:shock: WOW :shock: One of those bags would last me a while. Dang, that's alot of salt.

User avatar
Doug
Site Admin
Posts: 229
Joined: Tue Nov 30, 2004 11:26 am
My SetUp: 1984: 90 gal. saltwater, O'Dell tank, Oceanic Systems cabinet stand, (2) Perfecto 48" strip lights with Vita-Lite Power Twists, Aqualogy Bio-Grade Plus Undergravel filter, (2) Hagen Aquaclear 800 power heads, Eheim 2217 canister filter with Chemi-Pure, Hawaiian Marine Angstrom 2537 UV sterilizer

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by Doug » Wed Nov 18, 2009 8:37 pm

Interesting:
Aquarium water made seaworthy
Tons of salt added to create ocean habitat
Jim Tharpe - Staff
Tuesday, August 9, 2005

The ocean came to downtown Atlanta in a bag. Actually, a lot of very large bags.

When the folks at the Georgia Aquarium needed to transform 5 million or so gallons of Chattahoochee River water into seawater for creatures like giant grouper, tarpon and whale sharks, they turned to a product familiar to anyone with a saltwater fish tank at home.

Truckloads of Instant Ocean were shipped in 2,400-pound bags from the manufacturer in Mentor, Ohio.

"It's a combination of salts to replicate water in the open ocean," said Les Wilson, marketing manager for Instant Ocean. "It has all the trace metals and salt content that you would find if you took a sample from just about any ocean in the world."

The Georgia Aquarium, just north of Centennial Olympic Park in downtown Atlanta, will be the largest fish tank in the nation, and one of the largest in the world, when it opens its doors to the public Nov. 23. It will contain more than 100,000 fish and mammals. Two whale sharks, the world's largest fish, are already swimming in a tank the size of a football field.

Converting fresh water to seawater is a relatively recent concept.

When Chicago's Shedd Aquarium opened in 1929, it hauled saltwater from Key West, Fla., aboard custom-built rail cars. The Shedd, currently the largest indoor aquarium in the United States, began using Instant Ocean in the mid-1970s.

Wilson said his company shipped to the Georgia Aquarium about 50 truckloads of the product, which looks like finely ground table salt but "just a little whiter."

"We spent three days opening the bags and mixing it," said Jeff Swanagan, the aquarium's executive director. "It was a team-building experience."

The Instant Ocean salt was mixed with water from the city water supply, which comes from the Chattahoochee. The water was then circulated in the tanks for a couple of months before the first fish were placed there. "It has a few minerals in it, but it's mostly salt," Swanagan said.

The mixture is available at local pet and aquarium supply stores in containers of just a few pounds. Wilson said it takes about two cups of Instant Ocean to covert five gallons of fresh water into seawater.

The 1-ton-plus bags sold for commercial uses are known as "super sacks."

Officials at Instant Ocean and the Georgia Aquarium declined to disclose what it costs to convert 5 million gallons of river water into something akin to the ocean. However, 16 pounds purchased over the internet cost $20, and that's only enough to convert about 50 gallons of water. At that retail price --- bulk discounts aside --- the Georgia Aquarium conversion could run up to $2 million.
That means each sack is enough salt to make 7500 gallons. Tractor trailer GVW weight limits mean that only 17 of them can be shipped per truckload.

User avatar
Craig
Guppy Member
Posts: 15
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2009 7:52 pm
My SetUp: Custom profile field not completed.
Location: Gulfport ms

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by Craig » Sun Nov 29, 2009 2:35 pm

wouldn't you like to see that sitting in your local LFS

C-21 USAF
Discus Member
Posts: 192
Joined: Wed Oct 21, 2009 8:23 pm
My SetUp: Custom profile field not completed.

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by C-21 USAF » Sun Nov 29, 2009 9:17 pm

Instant Ocean has been good to me so far...

Redfish
Discus Member
Posts: 983
Joined: Sun Oct 25, 2009 6:49 am
My SetUp: AGA 150g 48x30x25, Reef Octopus Skimmer, Bio Pellet, Phosphate, Carbon reactor. Mostly a SPS coral tank with a few zoas a Green Polyp Toadstool, a Chalice or two and a couple of Scollys thrown in there. Top Off System and dosing pump system for Calcium and Alk.
Location: D'Iberville Mississippi

Re: Which Salt is the best for my tank? a Pic is worth a 1000...

Post by Redfish » Mon Nov 30, 2009 1:52 am

The only draw back with this salt, (and this maybe the same with all salts, don't know because this is the only salt that I have used) if you make your salt water up to much in advance, say a week, you get a brown film in your sw container and all over your cir. pump and heater. No big deal though, as I only put my salt in my container 2 days before using now. When I first saw this brown film I thought it was my container leaching something into the water but have since figured out it was the salt.

Post Reply